Skip to content
Ratebase
Menu

117 reviewed outcomes · 6 states

Case outcomes

Compare requested and authorized economics from completed proceedings across all six covered states.

Showing 117 of 117 outcomes

Authorized ROE is currently source-supported for 7 outcomes.

Rockland Electric

NJ · electric · ER25060374

Revenue requested
$18.74M
Revenue authorized
$15.25M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Jul 1, 2026
PPL Electric

PA · electric · R-2025-3057164

Revenue requested
$356.27M
Revenue authorized
$275M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Jul 1, 2026
Consumers Energy

MI · electric · U-21870

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
DTE Electric

MI · electric · U-21860

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
CenterPoint Energy Ohio

OH · gas · 24-0832-GA-AIR

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
$51.3M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Xcel Energy Michigan

MI · gas · U-21903

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Columbia Gas of Pennsylvania

PA · gas · R-2025-3053499

Revenue requested
$110.5M
Revenue authorized
$55.6M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Jan 1, 2026
Dominion Energy Virginia

VA · electric · PUR-2025-00058

Revenue requested
$822M
Revenue authorized
$565.7M
Requested ROE
10.4%
Authorized ROE
9.8%
Rates effective
Jan 1, 2026
Atlantic City Electric

NJ · electric · ER24110854

Revenue requested
$120M
Revenue authorized
$54M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Dec 1, 2025
Ohio Edison

OH · electric · 24-0468-EL-AIR

Revenue requested
$190.3M
Revenue authorized
$-5.3M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Mar 1, 2026
Consumers Energy

MI · gas · U-21806

Revenue requested
$248M
Revenue authorized
$157.5M
Requested ROE
10.25%
Authorized ROE
9.8%
Rates effective
Nov 1, 2025
UGI Gas

PA · gas · R-2024-3052716

Revenue requested
$110.4M
Revenue authorized
$70M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Oct 28, 2025
Atmos Energy Mid-Tex

TX · gas · OS-24-00019196

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Aug 1, 2025
Consumers Energy

MI · electric · U-21585

Revenue requested
$325M
Revenue authorized
$153.81M
Requested ROE
10.25%
Authorized ROE
9.9%
Rates effective
Apr 4, 2025
CenterPoint Houston Electric

TX · electric · 56211

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
DTE Electric

MI · electric · U-21534

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Xcel Energy Michigan

MI · electric · U-21565

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
PECO Electric

PA · electric · R-2024-3046931

Revenue requested
$464M
Revenue authorized
$354M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Jan 1, 2025
PECO Gas

PA · gas · R-2024-3046932

Revenue requested
$111M
Revenue authorized
$78M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Jan 1, 2025
New Jersey Natural Gas

NJ · gas · GR24010071

Revenue requested
$222.6M
Revenue authorized
$157M
Requested ROE
10.42%
Authorized ROE
9.6%
Rates effective
Elizabethtown Gas

NJ · gas · GR24020158

Revenue requested
$75.6M
Revenue authorized
$38M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
FirstEnergy Pennsylvania

PA · electric · R-2024-3047068

Revenue requested
$502M
Revenue authorized
$225M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Jan 1, 2025
Appalachian Power

VA · electric · PUR-2024-00024

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
AEP Texas

TX · electric · 56165

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
DTE Gas

MI · gas · U-21291

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Duquesne Light

PA · electric · R-2024-3046523

Revenue requested
$101M
Revenue authorized
$53M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Dec 20, 2024
PSE&G Electric

NJ · electric · ER23120924

Revenue requested
$522M
Revenue authorized
$440.5M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
PSE&G Gas

NJ · gas · GR23120925

Revenue requested
$423M
Revenue authorized
$270.8M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Michigan Gas Utilities

MI · gas · U-21540

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
UPPCO

MI · electric · U-21555

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Peoples Natural Gas

PA · gas · R-2023-3044549

Revenue requested
$156M
Revenue authorized
$93M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Sep 27, 2024
Alpena Power

MI · electric · U-21488

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Consumers Energy

MI · gas · U-21490

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Indiana Michigan Power

MI · electric · U-21461

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Atmos Energy Virginia

VA · gas · PUR-2023-00008

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Consumers Energy

MI · electric · U-21389

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
JCP&L

NJ · electric · ER23030144

Revenue requested
$184.95M
Revenue authorized
$85M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Jun 1, 2024
Roanoke Gas

VA · gas · PUR-2022-00205

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Appalachian Power

VA · electric · PUR-2023-00002

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Atlantic City Electric

NJ · electric · ER23020091

Revenue requested
$104.8M
Revenue authorized
$45M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Feb 1, 2024
UGI Electric

PA · electric · R-2022-3037368

Revenue requested
$11.4M
Revenue authorized
$9M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Oct 1, 2023
Southwestern Virginia Gas

VA · gas · PUR-2022-00196

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Entergy Texas

TX · electric · 53719

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
National Fuel Gas

PA · gas · R-2022-3035730

Revenue requested
$28.1M
Revenue authorized
$23M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Aug 1, 2023
Columbia Gas of Virginia

VA · gas · PUR-2022-00036

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
$40.3M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
May 31, 2023
Oncor

TX · electric · 53601

Revenue requested
$251M
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
10.3%
Authorized ROE
9.7%
Rates effective
South Jersey Gas

NJ · gas · GR22040253

Revenue requested
$73.1M
Revenue authorized
$25M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Columbia Gas of Pennsylvania

PA · gas · R-2022-3031211

Revenue requested
$82.2M
Revenue authorized
$44.5M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
PECO Gas

PA · gas · R-2022-3031113

Revenue requested
$82M
Revenue authorized
$54.8M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Jan 1, 2023
UGI Gas

PA · gas · R-2021-3030218

Revenue requested
$82.7M
Revenue authorized
$49M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Oct 29, 2022
El Paso Electric

TX · electric · 52195

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Elizabethtown Gas

NJ · gas · GR21121254

Revenue requested
$76.62M
Revenue authorized
$40M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
SPS Texas

TX · electric · 51802

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
SWEPCO Texas

TX · electric · 51415

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Columbia Gas of Pennsylvania

PA · gas · R-2021-3024296

Revenue requested
$98.3M
Revenue authorized
$58.5M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Dec 29, 2021
Duquesne Light

PA · electric · R-2021-3024750

Revenue requested
$85.8M
Revenue authorized
$45M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Jan 15, 2022
Rockland Electric

NJ · electric · ER21050823

Revenue requested
$16.9M
Revenue authorized
$9.65M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
PECO Electric

PA · electric · R-2021-3024601

Revenue requested
$246M
Revenue authorized
$132M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Jan 1, 2022
New Jersey Natural Gas

NJ · gas · GR21030679

Revenue requested
$165.67M
Revenue authorized
$79M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
UGI Electric

PA · electric · R-2021-3023618

Revenue requested
$8.7M
Revenue authorized
$6M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Nov 9, 2021
Michigan Gas Utilities

MI · gas · U-20718

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Atlantic City Electric

NJ · electric · ER20120746

Revenue requested
$71.8M
Revenue authorized
$43.7M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Jan 1, 2022
PECO Gas

PA · gas · R-2020-3018929

Revenue requested
$68.7M
Revenue authorized
$29.1M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
10.24%
Rates effective
Jul 1, 2021
Columbia Gas of Pennsylvania

PA · gas · R-2020-3018835

Revenue requested
$100.4M
Revenue authorized
$63.5M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
9.86%
Rates effective
Jan 23, 2021
Consumers Energy

MI · electric · U-20697

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
EPCOR Gas Texas

TX · gas · GUD-10988

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Appalachian Power

VA · electric · PUR-2020-00015

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
JCP&L

NJ · electric · ER20020146

Revenue requested
$186.9M
Revenue authorized
$94M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Nov 1, 2021
UGI Gas

PA · gas · R-2019-3015162

Revenue requested
$74.6M
Revenue authorized
$20M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Jan 1, 2021
South Jersey Gas

NJ · gas · GR20030243

Revenue requested
$75.3M
Revenue authorized
$39.5M
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
SPS Texas

TX · electric · 49831

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Texas Gas Service

TX · gas · GUD-10928

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
DTE Electric

MI · electric · U-20561

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Atmos West Texas

TX · gas · GUD-10900

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
AEP Texas

TX · electric · 49494

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
CenterPoint Houston Electric

TX · electric · 49421

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Indiana Michigan Power

MI · electric · U-20359

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
DTE Gas

MI · gas · U-20642

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Consumers Energy

MI · gas · U-20650

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
DTE Electric

MI · electric · U-20836

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
DTE Gas

MI · gas · U-20940

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Consumers Energy

MI · electric · U-20963

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Alpena Power

MI · electric · U-21045

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Xcel Energy Michigan

MI · electric · U-21097

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Consumers Energy

MI · gas · U-21148

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Consumers Energy

MI · electric · U-21224

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Xcel Energy Michigan

MI · gas · U-21226

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
UPPCO

MI · electric · U-21286

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
DTE Electric

MI · electric · U-21297

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Consumers Energy

MI · gas · U-21308

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Michigan Gas Utilities

MI · gas · U-21366

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
AES Ohio

OH · electric · 20-1651-EL-AIR

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
AEP Ohio

OH · electric · 20-585-EL-AIR

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Columbia Gas of Ohio

OH · gas · 21-637-GA-AIR

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Duke Energy Ohio

OH · electric · 21-887-EL-AIR

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Duke Energy Ohio

OH · gas · 21-888-GA-AIR

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Enbridge Gas Ohio

OH · gas · 23-894-GA-AIR

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
SPS Texas

TX · electric · 54634

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Greenlight Gas

TX · gas · OS-21-00008591

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Markham Gas

TX · gas · OS-22-00008970

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Texas Gas Service

TX · gas · OS-22-00009896

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Onalaska Water and Gas

TX · gas · OS-22-00010576

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
T & L Gas

TX · gas · OS-23-00012594

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
SiEnergy

TX · gas · OS-23-00013504

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Texas Gas Service

TX · gas · OS-23-00014399

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
CoServ Gas

TX · gas · OS-23-00014771

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
CenterPoint Entex

TX · gas · OS-23-00015513

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Texas Gas Service

TX · gas · OS-24-00017471

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Rockin M Gas

TX · gas · OS-24-00017711

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
West Texas Gas Utility

TX · gas · OS-24-00017816

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Atmos West Texas

TX · gas · OS-24-00018879

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Dominion Energy Virginia

VA · electric · PUR-2021-00058

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Old Dominion Power

VA · electric · PUR-2021-00171

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Virginia Natural Gas

VA · gas · PUR-2022-00052

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Dominion Energy Virginia

VA · electric · PUR-2023-00101

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Roanoke Gas

VA · gas · PUR-2024-00006

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective
Virginia Natural Gas

VA · gas · PUR-2024-00048

Revenue requested
Revenue authorized
Requested ROE
Authorized ROE
Rates effective

Missing values are shown as an em dash. ROE is displayed only when a reviewed official source supports a comparable requested or authorized value.